The three most important variables in exercise of any kind are frequency, duration and intensity. Yet, intensity is often the most overlooked of The Big 3, perhaps because it is not as readily measured… Or is it?
Some people prefer to judge intensity by signs such as how hard they breathe (by means of a talk test), or noticing how much they perspire. Unfortunately, both methods are at best an indirect means of gauging true aerobic intensity levels. A more accurate way to determine the intensity of aerobic exercise is to measure the pulse. This is because a person’s pulse is a reflection of how hard his or her heart is working. The heart level, in turn, determines oxygen uptake level: The higher the level, the greater the oxygen uptake.
There are two main ways in which someone can take his or her own pulse: using the fingers placed over a pulse point and counting, or using an electronic device to do most of the work.
The ‘Hands-on’ (Manual) Method
Using the manual method employs a combination of tactile sensation and some basic math to arrive at an approximate measurement of the pulse: Once your fingers find a pulse, count the number of beats you feel within the span of a single minute. It’s possible to estimate the per minute rate by counting for 10 seconds and multiplying this figure by 6, or count over 15 seconds and multiplying by 4, or over 30 seconds and doubling the result.
- Carotid Pulse (neck) – To take your heart rate at the neck, place your index and middle fingers on either side of the neck (being careful not to press too hard) at about the same level as the Adam’s apple, and then count the number of beats for a minute. Several methods can be used. Putting too much pressure on the carotid artery slows the heart rate almost instantly, resulting in an inaccurate measurement.
- Radial Pulse (wrist) – Another manual pulse-taking method involves the wrist. This method uses the radial artery at the base of the wrist. Place your index and middle fingers together on the other wrist, about 1/2 inch on the inside of the joint in line with the index finger. Use your index and middle fingers (not the thumb—it is supplied with its own artery), and then count the number of beats in a 6-second span, multiplying the result by a factor of 10.
Ultimately, both methods involve the use of technology – a watch or clock should be used for an objective and accurate measure of time.
These manual techniques, while quite handy (no pun intended), do have some inherent limitations. A primary issue is that in order to obtain an accurate measurement, it is necessary to stop exercising. Practice helps, but until one becomes proficient at obtaining a quick measurement, it to be expected that the pulse will start to drop quickly. This factor alone will often produce an inaccurate measurement. To complicate matters, in the case of the palpation of the carotid artery, the sudden slowing of heart rate can lead to dizziness, fainting, or in some cases, irregularities in heart rhythm.
For obvious reasons, electronic heart rate monitors have been designed to get around these issues and as a result, if used and worn correctly, they can yield much more accurate results.
The Body Electric: Electronic Heart Rate Monitoring
An electronic heart rate monitor uses a different means of measuring heart rate-mimicking the function of an electrocardiogram. A typical set-up consists of a strap worn the chest, and a wrist watch. The strap has two small electrodes that detect the equivalent of the “R” wave on an electrocardiogram (ECG). This R-wave represents the contraction of the heart, or “systole” phase, and the measurement isn’t affected by body movement. This measurement is transmitted to the wristwatch, which displays the information on its face. Some monitors are capable of recording heart rate changes over short time periods, and can record changes in heart rate to allow for later review or storage on an external computer. The data can be used to calculate calories burned, time elapsed in a target zone, and maximum oxygen intake, among other related measurements.
But portable electronic heart rate monitors are not without their own set of issues, either.
If the chest strap isn’t worn properly, it can cause inaccurate or no readings. In addition, many heart rate monitors require at least some perspiration to be present between the chest strap and the skin for best conductivity. A quick solution is to apply a small amount of lotion, water, or conductive gel until the amount of perspiration is sufficient to create good contact.